Where the wheel beat simply owning the stock
On 23 of 104 tickers the stock rose and the wheel still came out ahead of buying and holding, led by ABNB, SHOP, CVNA, SOXL, NOW, UBER — mostly high-volatility names (median realized vol 49% vs 30% overall), where premium on both sides was rich enough to make up for time spent in cash.
"Beat buy-and-hold" is the wrong test on its own
Counting every ticker, the wheel beat holding on 54 — but 31 of those were stocks that lost money, where sitting in cash collecting put premium naturally beat owning a falling share. Losing less than a collapsing stock is not a reason to pick it.
The highest wheel returns
By its own return, the wheel did best on GME, SMCI, PLTR, ARM, MU — strong risers, where even a strategy that spends much of its time in cash caught enough of the move. On the ten best stocks by buy-and-hold return, the wheel captured on average 47% of the stock's annual return.
How to read this table
vs hold / yr is the wheel's annual return minus buying the stock on day one. Wheel / yr includes interest on idle collateral. Time in shares is how often you actually owned the stock; the rest of the time you sat in cash selling puts. Tickers marked stock fell lost money as stocks. Premiums are modeled, not quoted — see the methodology. To change strikes or expiries, open any ticker or the wheel backtest; to price a real put, use the cash-secured put calculator.