S&P 500: JEPI, XYLD, SPYI vs SPY
From Aug 2022 to Oct 2026, SPY returned +19.2% a year with dividends reinvested. None of the covered-call ETFs beat it; JEPI returned +9.9%, XYLD returned +11.9%, SPYI returned +15.4%. The gap between the best (SPYI) and worst (JEPI) fund was 5.4% a year.
Selling 0.30-delta calls on SPY yourself (modeled) returned +18.6% a year, ahead of every fund; selling at-the-money calls, closer to what XYLD does, returned +13.1%. JEPI and XYLD and SPYI fell less than SPY at the worst point (max drawdown JEPI -13%, XYLD -16%, SPYI -16% vs -19%) — the cushion from premium is real but small next to a bear market.
How far to trust the modeled lines: XYLD sells at-the-money calls much like the modeled at-the-money strategy, and over this window the model returned +1.3% a year more than the real fund (about 0.6% of which is the fund's fee). Read the DIY figures as close to what a real fund delivered.
Nasdaq 100: JEPQ, QYLD vs QQQ
From May 2022 to Oct 2026, QQQ returned +21.4% a year with dividends reinvested. None of the covered-call ETFs beat it; JEPQ returned +16.3%, QYLD returned +11.7%. The gap between the best (JEPQ) and worst (QYLD) fund was 4.7% a year.
Selling 0.30-delta calls on QQQ yourself (modeled) returned +18.8% a year, ahead of every fund; selling at-the-money calls, closer to what QYLD does, returned +13.9%. JEPQ and QYLD fell less than QQQ at the worst point (max drawdown JEPQ -20%, QYLD -19% vs -23%) — the cushion from premium is real but small next to a bear market.
How far to trust the modeled lines: QYLD sells at-the-money calls much like the modeled at-the-money strategy, and over this window the model returned +2.3% a year more than the real fund (about 0.6% of which is the fund's fee). Read the DIY figures as optimistic by roughly that much.
Buy an income ETF or sell the calls yourself?
Head-to-head comparisons
Why covered-call ETFs trail the index in rising markets
Every covered-call fund sells away part of the upside in exchange for premium, then pays most of that premium out as distributions. In a strong market the upside it sold is worth more than the premium it collected, and that gap compounds. The funds differ in how much they sell: QYLD and XYLD write at-the-money index calls on the whole portfolio, giving up nearly all upside for the highest yield; JEPI and JEPQ hold an actively chosen stock portfolio and sell out-of-the-money calls through notes, keeping more upside; SPYI sells index options with a tax-efficient structure. A high distribution yield is not the same as a high return — what matters is the total return above, which already counts every distribution.
ETF or do it yourself?
An ETF does the work, needs no options approval and can be bought in small amounts; doing it yourself needs 100 shares per contract but lets you choose the strike and expiry, skip months, and avoid capping a stock you expect to run. The DIY lines here are modeled with the same Black–Scholes engine as the rest of this site (0.30-delta or at-the-money 30-day calls, rolled monthly, 5% haircut, no taxes or commissions), so treat them as a reference point, not a promise. Try other settings on SPY or QQQ, or price a single trade in the covered call calculator.
Fund returns use daily closing prices adjusted for distributions, from stockanalysis.com, and are after each fund's expense ratio. Our free data source only goes back to late 2021, so longer fund histories (QYLD and XYLD since 2013, JEPI since 2020) aren't shown. Each chart starts on the first day all its funds traded. Not investment advice.