Which setup held up best
The setup with the best median result was Quarterly, upside-friendly (+20%, 90 days) at -1.2% a year; the worst was Aggressive income at -7.0%. Calls written closer to the price collect more premium, but they get run over more often, and over years of mostly rising prices the buybacks win. No setup made money on net for the typical stock — the question is how much each one cost.
30 days or 45 days?
At 0.30 delta, 45-day calls had a median of -4.4% a year against -5.9% for 30-day calls, and were positive on 22 tickers versus 16. Longer expiries did a little better, mostly by writing strikes further from the price.
Roll, or let the shares go?
When a call finishes in the money you can buy it back and keep the shares (our default), or let the shares be called away. Letting them go and holding the cash (earning the 3-month T-bill rate in the model) did better on 46 of 104 tickers — mostly ones that fell afterwards. On anything that kept rising, being called away early meant missing the rest of the run. You can compare both on any ticker with the "if the call finishes in the money" choice in the covered call backtest.
What this means in practice
- On stocks that kept rising, lower-delta calls (written further out) cost the least — and not selling calls at all did better still.
- Closer strikes held up best on holdings that went sideways. What decides the cost is the stock's trend, not how quiet it is: a delta strike already sits further out on a jumpy stock, but a stock that keeps climbing runs through any strike more often than its delta implies.
- Check your own stock: results vary a lot by ticker. Start from the rankings or the calculator.
Premiums modeled with Black–Scholes from each stock's price history (methodology). Medians across all 104 tickers over Oct 2021 – Oct 2026, the common window used to compare every ticker. Not investment advice.