The boring stock that did not pay for its calls
The usual advice is to pick a calm dividend payer, sell calls against it and collect the premium. KO is about as calm as large stocks get, so I expected an easy case. It was not.
In this backtest I sold a 0.30-delta call every 30 days against 100 shares. The premium came to 9.0% a year, but buying calls back or settling them at a loss cost 10.7% a year. Net, the calls came to -1.7% a year. The covered call returned +10.6% a year, and simply holding KO returned +11.9%, so the call overlay trailed by 1.2 pts a year. Both figures include dividends, because the prices are dividend-adjusted.
The history here runs back to 2016, but the rankings compare every ticker over the same window, Oct 2021 – Oct 2026. Over that window KO's net from the calls was -4.2% a year, worse than its ten-year figure, while holding returned +14.7% a year. The covered-call return ranks 35 of 104 tickers, and KO is 3 of 5 among consumer staples on net call result.
What Coca-Cola did, and what the calls did with it
KO's typical volatility over this period was 14%, against a median of 30% across all 104 tickers I tested. Premium is paid for movement, and KO barely moves.
The year rows do not make a tidy pattern, and I will not force one.
| Year | Stock | Covered call | Difference (pts) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 partial | +0.9% | +1.3% | +0.4 pts |
| 2017 | +14.4% | +12.1% | -2.3 pts |
| 2018 | +6.8% | +2.9% | -3.9 pts |
| 2019 | +20.6% | +22.1% | +1.5 pts |
| 2020 | +2.5% | +8.0% | +5.5 pts |
| 2021 | +11.4% | +14.4% | +3.1 pts |
| 2022 | +10.6% | +6.6% | -4.0 pts |
| 2023 | -4.4% | -1.4% | +3.0 pts |
| 2024 | +8.9% | +5.4% | -3.5 pts |
| 2025 | +15.6% | +11.1% | -4.5 pts |
| 2026 partial | +34.2% | +25.1% | -9.0 pts |
Read 2020 with care: the model estimates option prices from recent price swings, which ran far above what options actually cost in the weeks after the March crash, so it overstates the premium collected then. Real buy-write funds trailed the S&P 500 in 2020.
Calendar-year total returns; the covered call is averaged over every start date, as in the chart above.
The calls finished ahead of holding in 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2023, and by +0.4 pts in the partial 2016 row. They finished behind in 2017, 2018, 2022, 2024, 2025 and 2026 so far. The 2020 row is the best at +5.5 pts, but I would not lean on it: the model likely overstates premiums after the March 2020 crash. Without it, the best years were 2021 at +3.1 pts and 2023 at +3.0 pts. 2023 was the only year KO lost money, -4.4% against -1.4% for the covered call.
The misses ran bigger than the wins. The worst full year was 2025, when KO rose +15.6% and the covered call made +11.1%, a gap of -4.5 pts. The partial 2026 row is the widest of all: KO is up +34.2% and the covered call +25.1%, a difference of -9.0 pts.
The deepest stretch for the stock ran from Feb 2020 to Mar 2020, a drawdown of -37%. The covered call fell -37% over the same stretch. The calls did not soften the drop, even though the model probably overstates the premiums collected in that crash.
Why a steady climber costs the call seller
KO returned +11.9% a year with dividends over these 10 years, a slow, steady climb. That drift is what the calls fought against.
A 0.30 delta is a rough guide to how often a call finishes in the money, about three cycles in ten. On KO the 0.30-delta call finished in the money in 34% of cycles, and the 0.40-delta call in 47%. When a stock drifts up, calls end above their strike more often than the delta suggests, and each time, buying the call back handed any gain past the strike to the buyer.
The damage also came in bursts. KO's worst month for a call seller began in Jan 2026, when the stock gained +17% and closing that call cost 13.5% of the share price at the time it was sold. That one call cost more than the 9.0% the calls collected in an average year, and it opened the 2026 rally behind the widest gap in the table.
I did not model early assignment ahead of ex-dividend dates, which can matter for a dividend payer. See the methodology page for what is and is not simulated.
How the other consumer staples fared
Among the five staples in the study, ranked by net result from the calls over Oct 2021 – Oct 2026, PepsiCo (PEP) came out best at +0.8%, the one staple where the calls added value, followed by Procter & Gamble (PG) at -1.3%. KO sat in the middle at -4.2%, ahead of Walmart (WMT) at -6.7% and Costco (COST) at -6.8%.
The spread from PEP to COST is wide. The wider list is on the rankings page.
If you own KO today
At $92 a share, 100 shares cost $9,200. The modeled 30-day 0.30-delta call today has a strike near $95, which is +3.2% above the price, and a premium of about $0.70 a share, or $70 a contract. That is 0.76% of the price. These are modeled premiums from the simulator, not live quotes.
The other setups tell a clearer story than the standard one. Moving to a 0.40-delta call made things worse at -2.4% net, with 47% of calls finishing in the money. Going to 45 days at 0.30 delta improved the net to -1.4%. The conservative 0.15-delta call netted -0.6%, with 14% of calls in the money. Strikes far above the price held up best: a call 10% out of the money netted +0.6%, and a quarterly call 20% out of the money also finished at +0.6%. Those collect little premium and give up almost no upside, so there is little to lose or gain.
The pattern in this backtest is that on KO, the further from the price the strike was, the better the calls did. You can test your own strike and expiry in the calculator, or read the strategy comparison for how the different setups work. The wheel version returned +9.4% a year, still 2.4 pts a year behind holding.
KO wheel strategy backtest — cash-secured puts plus covered calls on the same stock.
Covered calls on similar tickers: